As long as they are attractive. I'm average looking, not much guys give me a second look. She was sweet and kind and pure.
At least the stereotypical popular girls. If you are drop dead gorgeous and very quite, you will still be unpopular. I'm not the best with big openings, so I'll start simple. And for the longest while I was sure he liked me, I mean that's always how they showed it in the movies. So yes, it does happen.